10 Best Places To Buy Diamond Earrings Online

4 Prong Martini Diamond Earrings
For many people, buying diamond earrings is no easy task. First, there's the research. What do all the terms mean? Then, once you've got a grasp on the basics, you have to figure out how much a diamond earring is going to cost. After all, you don't want to pay too much for diamond earrings, but at the same time, you want to avoid the bottom of the barrel. Not only could cheap diamond earrings be poorly made, but they may contain diamonds with serious quality and durability issues. So where's the best place to buy diamond earrings online? This article will help address this question, allowing you to find the perfect pair of diamond earrings at a price that won't make you cringe.
Find your dream engagement ring and loose diamonds on Whiteflash. Their comprehensive website features an impressive selection of diamond earrings and other diamond jewelry, along with detailed filtering options to help you find exactly what you're looking for.

What to Look for When Shopping for Diamond Earrings Online

Cascade Lab Created Diamonds Earrings
When shopping for diamond earrings online, aim for certified diamonds. Look for grading reports from reputable laboratories, such as:
These certificates provide independent verification of the diamond’s cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. If there’s no certification, skip it. It’s your only way of confirming you’re getting what you paid for.
DIAMOND EARRINGS SEARCH
Item Code: 60082
14k White Gold 3 Prong Martini Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
14k White Gold 3 Prong Martini Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
Price:
$495.00
*Center diamond not included in price
Item Code: 60072
14k White Gold 4 prong Martini Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
14k White Gold 4 prong Martini Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
Price:
$495.00
*Center diamond not included in price
Item Code: 60062
14k White Gold 6 Prong Crown Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
14k White Gold 6 Prong Crown Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
Price:
$550.00
*Center diamond not included in price
Item Code: 61682-100L
1.00ctw 14k White Gold 4 Prong Classic Lab Created Diamond Earrings
1.00ctw 14k White Gold 4 Prong Classic Lab Created Diamond Earrings
Price:
$750.00
Select Earrings
LOAD MORE

High-Res Images & Videos: Get to Know Your Diamond Earrings Before You Buy

One of the main advantages of shopping online is the ability to examine multiple diamonds side by side, but only if the retailer provides high-resolution images and 360° videos. The best sites also offer virtual try-on tools, allowing you to see how the earrings will look when worn. If a diamond seller isn’t offering clear visuals, that’s a red flag.

Return Policies & Warranties: Buy with Confidence

Look for retailers that offer risk-free returns and solid warranties. You want a return window long enough to inspect the earrings in person, ideally 30 days or more. A good policy should also cover resizing, minor repairs, and cleaning services. Knowing you can return or exchange gives you peace of mind when buying remotely.

Customization & Style Range: Explore Options to Find Your Perfect Match

Whether you prefer classic studs, statement hoops, or elegant drop earrings, a quality online retailer should offer a range of styles and customization options. This includes selecting the metal type (white gold, yellow gold, or platinum), diamond shapes, and settings. Some even let you build your earrings from loose diamonds for complete control.

Transparent Pricing: Know What You're Paying For

Ensure pricing is transparent and accurately reflects current diamond market conditions. A good retailer will break down what you’re paying for: the diamond itself, the setting, and any value-added services. Be cautious of vague or bundled pricing, where it’s hard to determine how much of your spend is allocated toward actual diamond quality.

Sustainability: Shop for Ethically Sourced Diamonds

Ethical sourcing is increasingly important. Many online retailers now offer both natural and lab-grown diamonds, along with sourcing information to demonstrate that they’re conflict-free. If sustainability matters to you, check for brands that clearly state their ethical standards and supply chain practices.

Related Reading

10 Best Places To Buy Diamond Earrings Online

1. Whiteflash: The Power of Transparency

Promotional banner for Whiteflash's A CUT ABOVE® diamonds featuring the tagline

When you're shopping for diamond earrings online, confidence is everything. Whiteflash stands out as a trusted destination due to its transparency, quality-focused inventory, and expert guidance, particularly for those seeking more than just a basic pair of studs. Whiteflash is well known for its A CUT ABOVE® diamonds, a line of natural diamonds that meet rigorous standards for cut quality.
If you're buying diamond earrings and want exceptional sparkle and performance, these diamonds deliver. For shoppers seeking lab-grown options, Whiteflash also offers a carefully curated selection, providing flexibility without compromising quality.

Unparalleled Transparency and Detail in Diamond Selection

What sets Whiteflash apart is the level of detail available before you make a purchase. You can explore each diamond through high-definition imaging, detailed grading reports, and comparison tools that help you assess cut, clarity, and color. Whether you’re evaluating a simple solitaire style or something more intricate, you’ll know exactly what you’re buying. Support is another strength.

Expert Guidance and Premium Selection for Diamond Earrings

Whiteflash's GIA-trained staff are available to answer questions and guide you through the selection process. You’re not left on your own to interpret diamond specs or navigate complex choices. Expert help is just a call or message away.
Beyond quality and support, Whiteflash also offers access to premium designer settings from brands like Tacori and Verragio. That means your earrings can be tailored to your exact style, whether you're after timeless elegance or modern flair. With reliable shipping, clear return policies, and a reputation built on transparency, Whiteflash makes it easy to shop for diamond earrings online and get it right the first time.

2. James Allen: Unique Technology and Long-Term Support

James Allen is a good choice for shopping natural GIA-graded diamonds, lab-grown diamonds, and fine jewelry. The retailer utilizes a unique HD 360° high-resolution technology for viewing and inspecting diamonds, and offers long-term support.
As an online retailer of jewelry and diamonds, James Allen offers a wide range of options for buyers to consider when shopping for engagement rings. James Allen's product quality, customer service, price match policy, and other discounts are key factors that make them a good option for buying diamonds online. Also, check their True Hearts diamonds.

3. Blue Nile: Exquisite Designs and Craftsmanship

Exploring Blue Nile's designs and craftsmanship, especially their signature Astor Ideal Cut Diamonds, is recommended for fine diamond jewelry and gifts. The company is one of the first online fine jewelry retailers, transforming the online diamond shopping experience.
Blue Nile is also one of America's largest online retailers of diamonds and fine jewelry. Signet Jewelers acquired Blue Nile for $360m.

4. Brilliant Earth: Ethical Practices and Designer Jewelry

Brilliant Earth is an able choice for purchasing lab-grown diamonds and designer jewelry. They offer a wide selection of designer engagement rings and fine jewelry collections. Like other top-rated retailers, the company is renowned for maintaining the highest standards of ethics and environmental sustainability.
Brilliant Earth recently became a publicly traded company on the New York Stock Exchange. Moreover, Brilliant Earth is:
  • A certified and audited member of the Responsible Jewelry Council
  • One of the pioneering companies to provide blockchain-enabled diamonds
  • Has established rigorous protocols for tracing the origins of diamonds

5. Ritani: Exceptional Handcrafted Jewelry

Ritani was founded by a family of jewelers in 1999. The company is renowned for its handcrafted jewelry and customer service. Artisans in New York create Ritani's one-of-a-kind jewelry designs.
In addition to mountings and jewelry designs, Ritani provides complete pricing transparency, diamond market analysis, and a price-match policy (on virtual diamonds). You can check out how Ritani calculates diamond prices — they base it on wholesale prices, processing costs, and their own margins, and they make that breakdown available to customers.

6. Aurate: Unique Fine Jewelry

Aurate offers unique fine jewelry made from durable and sustainable materials at transparent prices. As a newcomer to the fine jewelry industry, the brand was created by Sophie Kahn and Bouchra Ezzahraoui in 2015 to offer elegant and classic jewelry designs with a dedication to affordability. Aurate is an exceptional choice for ethically sourced and sustainably crafted fine jewelry, engagement rings, and diamonds.

7. Hearts on Fire

Hearts on Fire is another option for ideal cut diamonds. The brand is known for its signature cutting style and consistent quality. Prices tend to be a bit higher compared to other online retailers, reflecting their branding and cut standards.

8. Tiffany & Co.: Luxury Diamond Experience

For buyers seeking a luxury experience, Tiffany & Co. requires no introduction. Since its inception, the company has earned a reputation for exceptional designs and quality. Tiffany diamonds are also renowned for their excellent quality. The company has expanded its online presence, offering superior products on its digital platforms.
Tiffany is such a well-known brand; its diamonds and engagement rings are quite expensive. Whiteflash can easily rival their quality at a more reasonable price point.

9. Costco: Retail Option for Diamonds

For shoppers seeking a retail option, Costco offers a vibrant jewelry section as part of its product offerings. Diamonds sold by Costco come with a GIA grading report for stones weighing a carat or more. However, many of their products do not provide an exact description and are instead described in general terms as having “VS2” clarity and “I” color. Our top-rated jeweler is still the better choice.

10. Jared: Local Retail Jewelry Store

Among the many retail jewelry brands owned by Signet Jewelers, such as:
  • Kay Jewelers
  • Zales
  • H. Samuel
  • Peoples
Among others, Jared The Galleria of Jewelry might be the best option for individuals who want to shop for an engagement ring locally.
The company has multiple locations, offers relatively premium merchandise, and consistently receives positive feedback. Financing options might also be readily available to clients.

How to Find the Best Place for Your Next Pair

Single Shared Prong Extra Small Diamond Hoop Earrings
Single Shared Prong Diamond Hoop Earrings from Whiteflash
When searching for the best place to buy diamond earrings online, start by deciding between natural and lab-grown diamonds. Both can be excellent options, but they suit different needs.
Natural diamonds tend to carry more traditional appeal and long-term value, while lab-grown diamonds are often more affordable and align with sustainable values. Your budget, style, and ethical preferences will shape this choice.

Look for Quality Certification

Verify that every pair you consider is accompanied by proper certification. GIA, IGI, or AGS reports confirm that the diamonds have been independently graded and certified. Without certification, there’s no reliable way to verify the quality you’re paying for, so it’s best to avoid uncertified pieces entirely.

Evaluate Customer Service

It’s also worth comparing how different retailers support customization and service. Some offer flexible design options, such as allowing you to choose your setting and diamond shape, while others focus on ready-to-ship collections. Strong customer support, clear return policies, and in-stock availability all contribute to making the experience smoother.

Read Recent Reviews

Before you commit, read up on recent reviews and testimonials. Verified buyer feedback can reveal how a retailer handles delivery times, returns, and service issues that often make or break the online buying experience.

Check for Updated Content

Take note of whether the retailer regularly updates their content, especially around diamond pricing and new arrivals. Brands that share educational blog posts, trend reports, and deal updates tend to stay engaged with their customers and responsive to market shifts.

Whiteflash: Your Trusted Source for Engagement Rings and Diamonds

When it comes to selecting the perfect engagement ring or diamond jewelry, you want to make the right choice with complete confidence. Whiteflash offers an extensive collection of loose diamonds, including our precision, natural A CUT ABOVE® diamonds as well as lab-grown options, alongside designer engagement ring settings from renowned names like Tacori and Verragio.

Empowering Informed Diamond Purchases

Our comprehensive diamond search tools, detailed grading reports, and high-definition imaging enable you to compare cuts, evaluate color and clarity, and understand precisely what you're getting before making a purchase. With our GIA-trained team available to guide you through the selection process, you have access to both the premium inventory and expert knowledge needed to make an informed decision, whether you're building:
From loose diamonds to complete engagement rings, we provide the quality, transparency, and customer care that make your investment pay off!

Related Reading

DIAMOND EARRINGS SEARCH
Item Code: 60082
14k White Gold 3 Prong Martini Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
14k White Gold 3 Prong Martini Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
Price:
$495.00
*Center diamond not included in price
Item Code: 60072
14k White Gold 4 prong Martini Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
14k White Gold 4 prong Martini Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
Price:
$495.00
*Center diamond not included in price
Item Code: 60062
14k White Gold 6 Prong Crown Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
14k White Gold 6 Prong Crown Diamond Earrings - Settings Only
Price:
$550.00
*Center diamond not included in price
Item Code: 61682-100L
1.00ctw 14k White Gold 4 Prong Classic Lab Created Diamond Earrings
1.00ctw 14k White Gold 4 Prong Classic Lab Created Diamond Earrings
Price:
$750.00
Select Earrings
LOAD MORE

10 Tips for Buying Diamond Earrings Online

14k White Gold 3 Prong

1. Research and Learn: Know Your Diamonds

Before making any major purchase, it’s always smart to research your options. Diamonds are no different. Begin by learning the basics of the 4Cs of diamond grading, which include carat weight, color, clarity, and cut.
Decide which qualities are most important to you. This decision, along with your budget, will help guide your diamond purchase.

2. Look for Specifics: Know What You’re Buying

When shopping online for diamonds, make sure you know exactly what you are buying. Some sites show diamonds with a range in carat weight, color, or clarity. For instance, a diamond may be listed as “0.90 – 1.04 carats,” which could indicate a stone that is just under one carat but may not be a good value. Instead, look for specifics on the diamond’s 4Cs, not a range.

3. Look for a Grading Report: Verify Diamond Quality

Make sure the diamond comes with an independent grading report, like those provided by GIA, which offers an unbiased analysis of the diamond’s 4Cs. A diamond’s value is largely determined by quality, so an objective, third-party assessment of the 4Cs is critical.

4. Verify the GIA Report with Report Check: Confirm Details

Suppose the diamond comes with a GIA report. In that case, you can verify the report details on Report Check, GIA’s secure online database and even print out a facsimile of the report when available. It’s a convenient way to ensure that the online product description aligns with the grading results.

5. Look for a Laser Inscription: For Added Security

For added security, find out if the diamond’s grading report number is laser-inscribed on its girdle. In some cases, the diamond will be inscribed before it is offered for sale, or it can be requested at the time of purchase.
In addition to the diamond’s unique GIA report number, the inscription can be a personal message or symbol for identification. The microscopic inscription is viewable under 10X magnification, using a jeweler’s loupe. Because it’s noted on the diamond’s GIA report, it will help ensure that the diamond you receive matches the report issued for it.

6. Know the Seller: Check Their Background

Once you’ve decided on the diamond that’s right for you, there are a few quick checks to do on the company you’re considering buying from.
You’ll want to know:
  • How long has the company been in business?
  • What kind of reviews has the company received?
  • Does it belong to any jewelry trade associations? (Associations often have ethical guidelines that members have to meet.)
  • Do they offer secure transactions?
  • Are the online representatives helpful?
  • What is the return policy?
  • Where is the seller located?
  • How will the diamond be shipped?
  • Is the shipment insured?
  • Is a signature required for delivery?
In addition to the above, if you’re buying from online auction sites, you’ll also want to look into buyer feedback and ratings and determine if the seller is providing sufficient evidence of the quality of the diamond offered for sale, such as photographs, a grading report, or a report number that can be verified.

7. Consider the Payment Method: Choose Wisely

Each online retailer or auction site will specify its method for accepting payment. If you paid with a credit card and encounter a problem with the purchase, most credit card companies offer dispute resolution options. Using a check or a money order for your purchase can reduce your options.

8. Proceed Cautiously with Out-of-Country Online Sites: Know the Risks

For example, U.S.-based consumers have options for recourse when buying from a U.S.-based company, such as filing complaints with the:
  • Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
  • Jewelers’ Vigilance Committee (JVC)
  • Better Business Bureau (BBB)
Pursuing a legal case in civil court. Websites that do not have a physical presence in your home country may be insulated from recourse, making attempts to recover funds frustrating.

9. Get the Diamond Appraised: Confirm Quality

Once your beautiful diamond is in hand, have an independent appraiser confirm that it matches the seller’s description and accompanying paperwork. The appraiser will also provide you with the value of the diamond for insurance purposes.

10. View the Diamond In Person: Try Before You Buy

The convenience of online shopping can’t be beat if you’re researching your options and trying to narrow your choices. Be aware that diamonds that appear to be almost identical on a grading report, with the same color, clarity, or cut grades, may look different from each other when viewed in person.
Your decision is a personal one, so seeing the diamond with your own eyes is the best way to determine if it’s right for you. So look for online sellers with retail stores and/or easy and flexible return policies.

Related Reading

  • Are Engagement and Wedding Rings Different
  • Diamond Shapes
  • Engagement Ring Styles
  • Diamond Setting
  • How to Choose an Engagement Ring to Suit Your Hand
  • Different Types of Engagement Rings
  • Different Stones for Engagement Rings

Find your Dream Engagement Ring and Loose Diamonds at Whiteflash Today!

When it comes to finding the perfect diamond, Whiteflash offers a stunning collection of options. They feature loose natural diamonds, lab-grown diamonds, and A CUT ABOVE diamonds, which are a cut above the rest, and that’s an understatement.
A CUT ABOVE diamonds are whiteflash’s exclusive, super ideal cut diamonds that are just extraordinary in terms of sparkle, beauty, and precision. The name comes from the fact that they score at least 1.5 on the HCA scale and will far exceed your expectations.
If you want a fantastic diamond for your engagement ring, Whiteflash is the place to find it.

Be Inspired By Our Designer Engagement Rings

Find the perfect Designer Ring for your special diamond by clicking the links below, and let us build the ultimate ring for the love of your life!
FIND DIAMONDS FIND JEWELRY
GO TO MY CART CONTINUE SHOPPING PROCEED TO CHECKOUT FIND DIAMONDS FIND JEWELRY
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE DIAMONDS
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE JEWELRY
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE DIAMONDS