Whiteflash vs. Blue Nile - Whiteflash Wins Hands Down!
September 20, 2012

Whiteflash vs. Blue Nile - Whiteflash Wins Hands Down!

When I first decided it was time to find an engagement ring for my girlfriend, I have to admit I didn't even know where to start. I went online, because that's pretty much where I do all my shopping, and starting reading reviews of various online jewelry stores. Right away, the choice came down to Blue Nile or Whiteflash. Blue Nile, because they are so famous and well-known, and Whiteflash, because they seemed to get great reviews and people seemed really happy with the customer service and the quality of the product. I had a pretty good idea of the ring and diamond I wanted. I wanted a pretty simple setting, with a few pave diamonds around the top and on the band, and a nice-sized diamond with a really good cut grade. So it was Blue Nile vs. Whiteflash, which one should I choose? I decided to contact both and see who would offer a better overall experience, and which company I would feel more comfortable handing over that kind of money to. Well, long story short, I now feel comfortable adding my own two cents to the many Whiteflash vs. Blue Nile reviews out there online: Whiteflash is the winner! The first thing I noticed was that every ring that turned up in my search had literally tons of information attached to it, like photos, certificates, special scans that let you see the "hearts and arrows", etc. etc. Even so, I was still more comfortable with Blue Nile at first, probably just because they are the most well-known online jewelry company. But once I contacted the Whiteflash people, every doubt was erased. The people I spoke to were all incredibly knowledgeable, and also very friendly, answering all my questions, finding me settings that matched my very vague description. They explained to me that the reason they know so much about everything listed on their site is that they actually own the diamonds listed on the site, unlike Blue Nile, who drop-ships from different suppliers around the world. (Working in online retail myself, I know that when you drop-ship, you just can't have the same level of quality control.) Anyway, I wasn't ready to make the purchase until I researched every single detail and asked every question in the book? I'm sure I wasn't the easiest customer, but Whiteflash people got back to me every time, with a quick response and a smiley face! All that brings me to the big day of the proposal. My girlfriend (now fiancé, thanks to Whiteflash!) was just blown away by the quality of the diamond and the setting. She told me she's been secretly looking at diamond rings for ages, and that this was the best diamond she'd ever seen. She kept turning her hand from side to side to watch the diamond sparkle in the candlelight. She couldn't believe that I bought the ring online, without ever seeing the diamond in person, and ended up with such an incredibly brilliant stone. The truth is? I'm probably going to end up regretting buying her ring from Whiteflash, because her birthday is coming up in about two months, and she's been dropping hints about the diamond stud earrings on the Whiteflash website! After that ring, I don't think I'm ever going to get away with buying her jewelry from anywhere else! So thanks again, Whiteflash people, and you'll be hearing from me soon!
John W., California, USA

RECENT REVIEWS

The proposal went great! She said yes, and absolutely loved the ring!
May 27, 2025
I had an outstanding experience working with Becca at Whiteflash! She was incredibly helpful, professional, and brought a great sense of humor to the process—which helped ease the nerves of picking out such an important piece. I was on a tight timeline before flying to Pittsburgh to propose, and Becca went above and beyond to help me find the perfect engagement ring and have it ready that same day. What really stood out was her personal touch—she even followed up via email to check in and see how the proposal went. That level of care and attention made the entire experience feel truly special. Thanks to her, everything went perfectly. I highly recommend Becca for anyone looking for exceptional service and a genuinely enjoyable jewelry-buying experience.
Ricardo S, Texas, USA
We both couldn’t stop staring at the ring; it was the perfect sparkler for such a magical moment.
May 23, 2025
I just have to say how thrilled we are with the custom setting and that A Cut Above diamond. The fire sparkle truly took my breath away, and the pave band makes it look so much bigger. I actually took the ring with me on a trip to Shika Snow Mountain in Yunnan, China. At the summit, with eight other peaks all around us, I proposed to me girlfriend and she said yes! We both couldn’t stop staring at the ring; it was the perfect sparkler for such a magical moment. Thank you for bringing our vision to life. Your craftsmanship and attention to detail made this ring unforgettable.
Jiawei L, California, USA
She said yes!
May 23, 2025
The proposal went without a hitch and she loved the ring! I appreciate all your help through this process as you really made this seamless. Thank you once again!
Erik S, Texas, USA
She loves it … and the spacer too!!
May 22, 2025
My goodness, it’s stunning — of course in bright sunshine — but I mean even in low light, they capture it all … The eternity just brings out the cut of both the solitaire and the eternity itself. Thank you immensely for all your help in the entire process … and can’t wait till the next one!
Richard K, Illinois, USA

Be Inspired By Our Designer Engagement Rings

Find the perfect Designer Ring for your special diamond by clicking the links below, and let us build the ultimate ring for the love of your life!
FIND DIAMONDS FIND JEWELRY
GO TO MY CART CONTINUE SHOPPING PROCEED TO CHECKOUT FIND DIAMONDS FIND JEWELRY
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE DIAMONDS
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE JEWELRY
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE DIAMONDS