Hearts on Fire vs. Whiteflash A CUT ABOVE
July 11, 2012

Hearts on Fire vs. Whiteflash A CUT ABOVE

I began looking at Hearts on Fire in our search in a traditional bricks and mortar store. I had heard of Hearts on Fire (HoF) before and one of my friends had gotten his fianc?©e a HoF engagement ring. We were absolutely blown away by the brilliance, fire and scintillation of these stones. We were quite turned off by the price but kept coming back to HoF as nothing compared at any of the stores. I had a few friends who had purchased online and highly recommended it. I started doing a lot of research (months of it and day after day) and came across sites like Pricescope.com. Long story short, by far one of the most trusted online retailers on these boards is Whiteflash.com. After a few months of getting comfortable with the idea of buying a diamond online I began to truly realize just how incredible these diamonds were. I kept hearing how they would stack up against a HoF diamond (or better) at a much reduced price because of the huge (40-50%) mark up on HoF diamonds. My experience with Whiteflash.com has been absolutely fantastic thus far! Customer service has been TOP NOTCH. No pressure whatsoever. Complete class and patience throughout the whole process. Never once did I feel like she was trying to sell me something. In fact on several occasions she steered me clear of a more expensive option they had. Very knowledgeable and prompt in answering any questions. They are more than happy to arrange a viewing to put any questions you have to rest. I am in the beginning stages of doing a custom setting, and so far it has been a very pleasant experience. As with many people, my girlfriend and I began our search in a traditional bricks and mortar store. I had heard of Hearts on Fire (HoF) before and one of my friends had gotten his fianc?©e a HoF engagement ring. We were absolutely blown away by the brilliance, fire and scintillation of these stones. We were quite turned off by the price but kept coming back to HoF as nothing compared at any of the stores. I decided I wanted to compare the Hearts on Fire diamond to the Super Ideal A Cut Above Diamond. I made sure to order identical G SI1 Super Ideal cut diamonds to fairly compare them. I ordered a diamond from Whiteflash and had it delivered to a 3rd party appraiser. Upon finally viewing one of these beauties, I can ASSURE you they are every bit as good as a Hearts on Fire diamond. However, it was once I took the diamond outside under a natural light source that I was COMPLETELY blown away. Dare I say it outclassed the HoF diamond to a fair degree. Not blew it away, but a slight edge to the A Cut Above Diamond from Whiteflash. It actually blinded me! It literally took me a few seconds to adjust the dancing light that was coming from this diamond. I would say the ACA diamond was nearly a shade whiter than the HoF. I would say the scintillation and sparkle are fairly comparable with a slight edge in contrast and ""flash"" or fire going to the ACA. The cuts on both of these diamonds is unparalleled. No doubt about it, the HoF diamond is world class and as good of a cut as money can buy. The ACA diamond is ABSOLUTELY on the same level as the HoF diamond. I dare say even A CUT ABOVE. Sorry. I had to do it. I would recommend the Whiteflash staff to anyone who is considering a diamond purchase. You owe it to yourself to at least have a look and compare! In fact, I have a few friends who may be looking in the near future. I will be sure to pass along my knowledge to them.
Tim D., Michigan, USA

RECENT REVIEWS

I received my ring today, and it’s absolutely stunning!
May 21, 2025
I love it and so so glad I went with the bigger stone. It honestly doesn’t look too big on my hand and I can’t get enough of it. Thank you all so much for your advice, patience, and support in helping me choose the perfect one. I’m completely over the moon! I love the chain and pendant as well. It’s just perfect. Thank you so much again! I hope we get to work again in the future.
Amy K, Massachusetts, USA
The diamond ring is beautiful!
May 20, 2025
I was happily surprised with the ring when I opened the box up! The diamond is beautiful and the ring setting is just the same quality! Thank you!
Clinton S, Nevada, USA
100 percent perfection, my future bride is ecstatic! ❤️
May 19, 2025
Brittany was the best during my purchase. Her response times via both email and phone are indescribable. Purchasing an engagement ring trying to ensure your money is well spent and trying very hard to get it right as selecting the ring for your future wife can be taxing on the man. She went way above and beyond, and all I can say is she helped me nail it. 100 percent perfection, my future bride is ecstatic! The proposal was beautiful and the look on her face as she saw the ring in the little beach chair positioned on the starfish as she read the message in the bottle, was one I'll never forget. She was immediately taken by the ring, such a huge smile on her face, has told me a hundred times how beautiful it is and how much she loves it and how I just nailed it from the ring to the presentation. I won't lie, I've glanced at her hand so many times and it is so perfect on her hand. And Oh My God...the sparkle on the beach I even saw it sparkle from across the room at a restaurant as I was walking back. So indescribably happy, it was all perfect! Thank you for all of your help and the fantastic communication! A fella gets anxious with all of this, but you made it easy. Tks Brittany!!
Adam, Alaska, USA
The diamonds is gorgeous!
May 18, 2025
I want to take a moment to recognize Brittany for her truly exceptional service. From the very beginning, Brittany demonstrated a remarkable level of professionalism, attention to detail, and a genuine willingness to go above and beyond. Her responsiveness and care made the entire experience smooth, enjoyable, and stress-free. It’s rare to find someone so committed to excellence and so attentive to every need—she truly embodies the spirit of outstanding customer service. Thank you, Brittany, for making this experience so memorable. Whiteflash is lucky to have you!
Ricardo L, Puerto Rico

Be Inspired By Our Designer Engagement Rings

Find the perfect Designer Ring for your special diamond by clicking the links below, and let us build the ultimate ring for the love of your life!
FIND DIAMONDS FIND JEWELRY
GO TO MY CART CONTINUE SHOPPING PROCEED TO CHECKOUT FIND DIAMONDS FIND JEWELRY
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE DIAMONDS
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE JEWELRY
COMPARE REMOVE ALL FIND MORE DIAMONDS